Biomechanical Behaviour of Different Materials in Partial Fixed Dental Prosthesis: A Finite Element Analysis
Keywords:
Mandible, Material, Ceramic, Prosthesis, Finite Element Method, Characterization
Abstract
In partial fixed dental prostheses/bridge crowns, to create an adequate aesthetic; composition specification must be realistic, reflects individuality and visual harmony. On the other hand, it must be biocompatible, non-toxic and must be fulfill mechanic specifications of the mandible and teeth. Many materials have been used for restorative purposes in dentistry until today.
In this study, a three-dimensional mandible model was obtained from computed tomography (CT) images, and partial fixed dental prostheses/bridge crowns are created in the frontal region of mandible. For both (healthy mandible and prosthesis) models, the prosthesis geometries were designed with three different biocompatible materials (Titanium Alloy, Chrome Cobalt, Stainless Steel) and their mechanical analyzes were completed separately for each one, and compared with ANSYS® WORKBENCH software.
References
[1] Malkondu Ö, Tinastepe N, Akan E, Kazazoğlu E. An overview of monolithic zirconia in dentistry. Biotechnology & Biotechnological Equipment, 30(4):644-52, 2016.
[2] Yoon HI, Yeo IS, Yi YJ, Kim SH, Lee JB, Han JS. Effect of surface treatment and liner material on the adhesion between veneering ceramic and zirconia. Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials 40:369-74, 2014.
[3] Özden Y, E, Monolithic Zirconia Effect of Change in Sintering Time on Marginal and Internal Range in Restorations, PhD Thesis, Hacettepe University, 2017.
[4] Carames J, Tovar Suinaga L, Yu YC, Perez A, Kang M. Clinical Advantages and Limitations of Monolithic Zirconia Restorations Full Arch Implant Supported Reconstruction: Case Series. International journal of dentistry, 2015:392-496, 2015.
[5] Alpert B, Engelstad M, Kushner GM. Invited review: small versus large plate fixation of mandibular fractures. J Craniomaxillofac Trauma. 1999;5: 33-9.
[6] Åžirin Y, Said M, Limani E, Soley S, : Sagittal Split Effects of Osteotomy Technique on In-Vitro Biomechanical Strength of Titanium Plates, Ä°stanbul University Journal of the Faculty of Dentistry, 45(3), 2011.
[8] Takahashi, H, Moriyama, S., Furuta, H., Matsunaga, H, Sakamoto, Y., Kikuta, T, “Split Ramus Osteotomy Fixed with Resorbable Compared with Titanium Bicortical Screws in Mandibles of Sheep,†Head & Face Medicine, 6:4, 2010.
[9] Chuong, C, Borotikar, B, Schwartz-Dabney, C, Douglas Sinn, P., “Mechanical Characteristics of the Mandible After Bilateral Sagittal Split Ramus Osteotomy: Comparing 2 Different Fixation Techniques,†American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 63:68-76, 2005.
[10] Grahramanzadeh ASL, H., Kovacı, H., Kaymaz, İ, Alsaran, A, Çelik, İ, “Simulation of placement of mini plates used on jaw fractures on sheep jaw and stress analysis with FEM†TİSKON 2011, Samsun, 31-39, 2011.
[11] Karatasli O, Kursoglu P, Capa N, Kazazoglu E. Comparison of the marginal fit of different coping materials and designs produced by computer aided manufacturing systems. J. Dental Materials, 30(1):97-102, 2011.
[12] Esen A., Comparison of Stability of Titanium and Resorbable Plate and Screw Fixations in Mandible Angulus Fractures, Doctoral Thesis, Selçuk Universities, 2008.
[13] Ayalı A., Investigation of Biomechanical Effects of Different Fixation Methods Applied in Favorable and Unfavorable Fractures of Mandibular Angulus Region by Finite Element Analysis Method, Ph.D. Thesis, Near East University, 2012.
[14] Denry I, Kelly JR. State of the art of zirconia for dental applications. Dental materials: official publication of the Academy of Dental Materials, ;24(3):299-307, 2008.
[16] Ömezli M., Dayı E., Ayrancı F., Kaya G., Mandibular Condyle Fractures And Treatment Methods, Cumhuriyet Univ. Dent Journal., 15(1):63-70, 2011.
[17] Ministry of Health Ankara Provincial Health Directorate Emergency Health Services Branch, Basic First Aid Practices Training Book, Ankara, 2006.
[18] İrkören S., Sivrioğlu N., Bulut B., Sonel A., Ceylan E. Retrospective Analysis of 63 Mandibular Fracture Cases Operated Within Three Years. Adnan Menderes University Faculty of Medicine Journal,12(3) 2011.
[19] Akdemir K., Lower Jaw Fractures and Treatment Methods in Children, Graduation Thesis, Ege University, Faculty of Dentistry, 2007.
[20] Gutwald R, Alpert B, Schmelzeisen R. Principle and stability of locking plates. Keio J Med., 52(1):21-24, 2003.
[21] Alpert B, Gutwald R, Schmelzeisen R. New innovations in craniomaxillofacial fixation: the 2.0 lock system. Keio J Med 52(2):120-127, 2003.
[22] Chiodo TA, Ziccardi VB, Janal M, Sabitini C. Failure strength of 2.0 locking versus 2.0 conventional Synthes mandibular plates: A laboratory model. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 64(10):1475-1479, 2006.
[23] Tao J, Han D. The effect of finish line curvature on marginal fit of all-ceramic CAD/CAM crowns and metal-ceramic crowns. Quintessence international (Berlin, Germany:1985).;40(9):745-52, 2009.
[24] Pimenta MA, Frasca LC, Lopes R, Rivaldo E. Evaluation of marginal and internal fit of ceramic and metallic crown copings using x-ray microtomography (micro-CT) technology. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry,114(2):223-8, 2015.
[25] Boitelle P, Mawussi B, Tapie L, Fromentin O. A systematic review of CAD/CAM fit restoration evaluations. Journal of oral rehabilitation, 41(11):853-74, 2014.
[26] Ueda K, Beuer F, Stimmelmayr M, Erdelt K, Keul C, Guth JF. Fit of 4-unit FDPs from CoCr and zirconia after conventional and digital impressions. Clinical oral investigations, 20(2):283-9, 2016.
[27] Belli R, Frankenberger R, Appelt A, Schmitt J, Baratieri LN, Greil P, et al. Thermalinduced residual stresses affect the lifetime of zirconia-veneer crowns. Dental materials: official publication of the Academy of Dental Materials,29(2):181- 90, 2013.
[28] Zhang H, Kim BN, Morita K, Keijiro Hiraga HY, Sakka Y. Effect of sintering temperature on optical properties and microstructure of translucent zirconia prepared by highpressure spark plasma sintering. Science and technology of advanced materials, 12(5):055003, 2011.
[29] Almazdi AA, Khajah HM, Monaco EA, Jr., Kim H. Applying microwave technology to sintering dental zirconia. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry, 108(5):304-9, 2012.
[30] Lee KH, Yeo IS, Wu BM, Yang JH, Han JS, Kim SH, et al. Effects of Computer-Aided Manufacturing Technology on Precision of Clinical Metal-Free Restorations. BioMed research international, 619-627 , 2015.
[31] Hamza TA, Ezzat HA, El-Hossary MM, Katamish HA, Shokry TE, Rosenstiel SF. Accuracy of ceramic restorations made with two CAD/CAM systems. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry,109(2):83-7, 2013.
[32] Atik F., Comparison of Material and Geometry Differences of Plate-Fixators Used in Mandibular Fractures According to Fracture Types, Master Thesis, Düzce University, 2013.
[33] As N. T., Retrospective Analysis of Facial Fracture Etiology, PhD Thesis, HaydarpaÅŸa Numune Training and Research Hospital, 2008.
[34] Açıkel C., Saray A., Yılmaz K., A Case of Maxillofacial Trauma Requiring Re-Surgery, Acıbadem University Journal of Health Sciences, 2(2), 2011.
[35] Şirin Y., Said M., Limani E., Soley S., The Influences Of Two Sagıttal Splıt Osteotomy Technıques On The In Vıtro Bıomechanıcal Stabılıty Of Tıtanıum Plates, İstanbul Üniversitesi Diş Hekimliği Fakültesi Dergisi, ,45(3), 2011.
[36] Alnıaçık G., Investigation of Stress Generated by Mandibular Overdenture Prostheses on Implants Applied at Different Levels, Ph.D. Thesis, Selcuk University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2011.
[37] Deniz K., Investigation of the Effect of Different Fracture Types on the Stability of Titanium Plate and Screw Fixation in Mandible Angulus Fractures by Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, BaÅŸkent University Institute of Health Sciences, 2011.
[38] Müftüoğlu G., Evaluation of Locked and Unlocked Plate and Screw Systems in Mandibular Lateral Defects by Three-Dimensional Modeling and Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, Başkent University, 2013.
[39] Çilingir A., Experimental and Numerical Analysis of Stresses in the Lower Jaw in Lower and Full Implant Supported Dentures, Ph.D. Thesis, Istanbul University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2005.
[40] Karatasli O, Kursoglu P, Capa N, Kazazoglu E. Comparison of the marginal fit of different coping materials and designs produced by computer aided manufacturing systems. Dental Materials Journal.;30(1):97-102, 2011.
[41] KayabasΙ O, YüzbasΙoglu E, ErzincanlΙ F. Static, dynamic and fatigue behaviors of dental implant using finite element method. Adv Eng Softw, 37(10): 649-658, 2006.
[42] Özkan, A., “Computer Aided Three Dimensional Modeling and Kinematic Analysis of Human Knee Mechanism â€, Ph.D. Thesis, Kocaeli University Institute of Science Mechanical Education, Kocaeli, 2010.
[43] OÄŸuz Y., Investigation of the Use of Locked Screw and Plate System in Sagittal Split Ramus Osteotomy with Three-Dimensional Modeling and Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, BaÅŸkent University, Faculty of Dentistry, 2007.
[44] Arat Z., Investigation of the Effect of Implant Number and Holder Type on Bone Stress Distributions in Mandibular Implant Supported Removable Dentures by Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, Istanbul University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2010.
[45] Sancaklı E., Evaluation of Stress Distribution of Bar Supported Implant Prosthesis in Lower Toothless Jaw Using Finite Elements Stress Analysis Method, Ph.D. Thesis, Istanbul University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2006
[46] Ãœnal D., “Medical Imaging Techniques â€, Master Thesis, Gazi University Gazi Education Faculty, Department of Education Science and Mathematics Education, Ankara, 2008.
[47] Çelik T., Stress Distribution of Dynamic Hip Nail in the Femoral Fractures Between the Trochanter According to the Location of the Hip, Master Thesis, Kocaeli University, Institute of Science, 2012.
[48] Türker, M. ve Yücetaş, Ş., Oral, Dental and Maxillofacial Diseases and Surgery, (3rd. Ed.), Özyurt Matbaacılık, 2004.
[49] Atik F., Özkan A., Uygur İ., Comparison of Stress and Displacement Behavior of Human Thigh Bone and Hip Replacement, Sakarya University Journal of Institute of Science, 16(3), 249-253, 2012.
[2] Yoon HI, Yeo IS, Yi YJ, Kim SH, Lee JB, Han JS. Effect of surface treatment and liner material on the adhesion between veneering ceramic and zirconia. Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials 40:369-74, 2014.
[3] Özden Y, E, Monolithic Zirconia Effect of Change in Sintering Time on Marginal and Internal Range in Restorations, PhD Thesis, Hacettepe University, 2017.
[4] Carames J, Tovar Suinaga L, Yu YC, Perez A, Kang M. Clinical Advantages and Limitations of Monolithic Zirconia Restorations Full Arch Implant Supported Reconstruction: Case Series. International journal of dentistry, 2015:392-496, 2015.
[5] Alpert B, Engelstad M, Kushner GM. Invited review: small versus large plate fixation of mandibular fractures. J Craniomaxillofac Trauma. 1999;5: 33-9.
[6] Åžirin Y, Said M, Limani E, Soley S, : Sagittal Split Effects of Osteotomy Technique on In-Vitro Biomechanical Strength of Titanium Plates, Ä°stanbul University Journal of the Faculty of Dentistry, 45(3), 2011.
[8] Takahashi, H, Moriyama, S., Furuta, H., Matsunaga, H, Sakamoto, Y., Kikuta, T, “Split Ramus Osteotomy Fixed with Resorbable Compared with Titanium Bicortical Screws in Mandibles of Sheep,†Head & Face Medicine, 6:4, 2010.
[9] Chuong, C, Borotikar, B, Schwartz-Dabney, C, Douglas Sinn, P., “Mechanical Characteristics of the Mandible After Bilateral Sagittal Split Ramus Osteotomy: Comparing 2 Different Fixation Techniques,†American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 63:68-76, 2005.
[10] Grahramanzadeh ASL, H., Kovacı, H., Kaymaz, İ, Alsaran, A, Çelik, İ, “Simulation of placement of mini plates used on jaw fractures on sheep jaw and stress analysis with FEM†TİSKON 2011, Samsun, 31-39, 2011.
[11] Karatasli O, Kursoglu P, Capa N, Kazazoglu E. Comparison of the marginal fit of different coping materials and designs produced by computer aided manufacturing systems. J. Dental Materials, 30(1):97-102, 2011.
[12] Esen A., Comparison of Stability of Titanium and Resorbable Plate and Screw Fixations in Mandible Angulus Fractures, Doctoral Thesis, Selçuk Universities, 2008.
[13] Ayalı A., Investigation of Biomechanical Effects of Different Fixation Methods Applied in Favorable and Unfavorable Fractures of Mandibular Angulus Region by Finite Element Analysis Method, Ph.D. Thesis, Near East University, 2012.
[14] Denry I, Kelly JR. State of the art of zirconia for dental applications. Dental materials: official publication of the Academy of Dental Materials, ;24(3):299-307, 2008.
[16] Ömezli M., Dayı E., Ayrancı F., Kaya G., Mandibular Condyle Fractures And Treatment Methods, Cumhuriyet Univ. Dent Journal., 15(1):63-70, 2011.
[17] Ministry of Health Ankara Provincial Health Directorate Emergency Health Services Branch, Basic First Aid Practices Training Book, Ankara, 2006.
[18] İrkören S., Sivrioğlu N., Bulut B., Sonel A., Ceylan E. Retrospective Analysis of 63 Mandibular Fracture Cases Operated Within Three Years. Adnan Menderes University Faculty of Medicine Journal,12(3) 2011.
[19] Akdemir K., Lower Jaw Fractures and Treatment Methods in Children, Graduation Thesis, Ege University, Faculty of Dentistry, 2007.
[20] Gutwald R, Alpert B, Schmelzeisen R. Principle and stability of locking plates. Keio J Med., 52(1):21-24, 2003.
[21] Alpert B, Gutwald R, Schmelzeisen R. New innovations in craniomaxillofacial fixation: the 2.0 lock system. Keio J Med 52(2):120-127, 2003.
[22] Chiodo TA, Ziccardi VB, Janal M, Sabitini C. Failure strength of 2.0 locking versus 2.0 conventional Synthes mandibular plates: A laboratory model. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 64(10):1475-1479, 2006.
[23] Tao J, Han D. The effect of finish line curvature on marginal fit of all-ceramic CAD/CAM crowns and metal-ceramic crowns. Quintessence international (Berlin, Germany:1985).;40(9):745-52, 2009.
[24] Pimenta MA, Frasca LC, Lopes R, Rivaldo E. Evaluation of marginal and internal fit of ceramic and metallic crown copings using x-ray microtomography (micro-CT) technology. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry,114(2):223-8, 2015.
[25] Boitelle P, Mawussi B, Tapie L, Fromentin O. A systematic review of CAD/CAM fit restoration evaluations. Journal of oral rehabilitation, 41(11):853-74, 2014.
[26] Ueda K, Beuer F, Stimmelmayr M, Erdelt K, Keul C, Guth JF. Fit of 4-unit FDPs from CoCr and zirconia after conventional and digital impressions. Clinical oral investigations, 20(2):283-9, 2016.
[27] Belli R, Frankenberger R, Appelt A, Schmitt J, Baratieri LN, Greil P, et al. Thermalinduced residual stresses affect the lifetime of zirconia-veneer crowns. Dental materials: official publication of the Academy of Dental Materials,29(2):181- 90, 2013.
[28] Zhang H, Kim BN, Morita K, Keijiro Hiraga HY, Sakka Y. Effect of sintering temperature on optical properties and microstructure of translucent zirconia prepared by highpressure spark plasma sintering. Science and technology of advanced materials, 12(5):055003, 2011.
[29] Almazdi AA, Khajah HM, Monaco EA, Jr., Kim H. Applying microwave technology to sintering dental zirconia. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry, 108(5):304-9, 2012.
[30] Lee KH, Yeo IS, Wu BM, Yang JH, Han JS, Kim SH, et al. Effects of Computer-Aided Manufacturing Technology on Precision of Clinical Metal-Free Restorations. BioMed research international, 619-627 , 2015.
[31] Hamza TA, Ezzat HA, El-Hossary MM, Katamish HA, Shokry TE, Rosenstiel SF. Accuracy of ceramic restorations made with two CAD/CAM systems. The Journal of prosthetic dentistry,109(2):83-7, 2013.
[32] Atik F., Comparison of Material and Geometry Differences of Plate-Fixators Used in Mandibular Fractures According to Fracture Types, Master Thesis, Düzce University, 2013.
[33] As N. T., Retrospective Analysis of Facial Fracture Etiology, PhD Thesis, HaydarpaÅŸa Numune Training and Research Hospital, 2008.
[34] Açıkel C., Saray A., Yılmaz K., A Case of Maxillofacial Trauma Requiring Re-Surgery, Acıbadem University Journal of Health Sciences, 2(2), 2011.
[35] Şirin Y., Said M., Limani E., Soley S., The Influences Of Two Sagıttal Splıt Osteotomy Technıques On The In Vıtro Bıomechanıcal Stabılıty Of Tıtanıum Plates, İstanbul Üniversitesi Diş Hekimliği Fakültesi Dergisi, ,45(3), 2011.
[36] Alnıaçık G., Investigation of Stress Generated by Mandibular Overdenture Prostheses on Implants Applied at Different Levels, Ph.D. Thesis, Selcuk University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2011.
[37] Deniz K., Investigation of the Effect of Different Fracture Types on the Stability of Titanium Plate and Screw Fixation in Mandible Angulus Fractures by Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, BaÅŸkent University Institute of Health Sciences, 2011.
[38] Müftüoğlu G., Evaluation of Locked and Unlocked Plate and Screw Systems in Mandibular Lateral Defects by Three-Dimensional Modeling and Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, Başkent University, 2013.
[39] Çilingir A., Experimental and Numerical Analysis of Stresses in the Lower Jaw in Lower and Full Implant Supported Dentures, Ph.D. Thesis, Istanbul University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2005.
[40] Karatasli O, Kursoglu P, Capa N, Kazazoglu E. Comparison of the marginal fit of different coping materials and designs produced by computer aided manufacturing systems. Dental Materials Journal.;30(1):97-102, 2011.
[41] KayabasΙ O, YüzbasΙoglu E, ErzincanlΙ F. Static, dynamic and fatigue behaviors of dental implant using finite element method. Adv Eng Softw, 37(10): 649-658, 2006.
[42] Özkan, A., “Computer Aided Three Dimensional Modeling and Kinematic Analysis of Human Knee Mechanism â€, Ph.D. Thesis, Kocaeli University Institute of Science Mechanical Education, Kocaeli, 2010.
[43] OÄŸuz Y., Investigation of the Use of Locked Screw and Plate System in Sagittal Split Ramus Osteotomy with Three-Dimensional Modeling and Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, BaÅŸkent University, Faculty of Dentistry, 2007.
[44] Arat Z., Investigation of the Effect of Implant Number and Holder Type on Bone Stress Distributions in Mandibular Implant Supported Removable Dentures by Finite Element Analysis, Ph.D. Thesis, Istanbul University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2010.
[45] Sancaklı E., Evaluation of Stress Distribution of Bar Supported Implant Prosthesis in Lower Toothless Jaw Using Finite Elements Stress Analysis Method, Ph.D. Thesis, Istanbul University, Institute of Health Sciences, 2006
[46] Ãœnal D., “Medical Imaging Techniques â€, Master Thesis, Gazi University Gazi Education Faculty, Department of Education Science and Mathematics Education, Ankara, 2008.
[47] Çelik T., Stress Distribution of Dynamic Hip Nail in the Femoral Fractures Between the Trochanter According to the Location of the Hip, Master Thesis, Kocaeli University, Institute of Science, 2012.
[48] Türker, M. ve Yücetaş, Ş., Oral, Dental and Maxillofacial Diseases and Surgery, (3rd. Ed.), Özyurt Matbaacılık, 2004.
[49] Atik F., Özkan A., Uygur İ., Comparison of Stress and Displacement Behavior of Human Thigh Bone and Hip Replacement, Sakarya University Journal of Institute of Science, 16(3), 249-253, 2012.
Published
2020-12-31
How to Cite
Ozkan, A., & Pusur, M. (2020). Biomechanical Behaviour of Different Materials in Partial Fixed Dental Prosthesis: A Finite Element Analysis. Journal of Engineering Research and Applied Science, 9(2), 1486-1495. Retrieved from http://journaleras.com/index.php/jeras/article/view/210
Section
Articles
